Updated:22 October 2026
Rank 1-22 of the best Pacifiers
Our recommendation Price Customer rating
1. Comparison winner
Tommee Tippee Anytime 6 Pack Dummies
Tommee Tippee Anytime 6 Pack Dummies
Available again soon
free shipping
  • air holes in the soother allow the skin to breathe
  • symmetrical teat ensures it always sits upright
  • specially designed shields provide a comfortable fit
Our rating
9,8
very good
100+ purchases last month
2. Best value
Tommee Tippee Ultimate Fit Orthodontic Dummies 18–36 Months, Silicone, Pack of 4
Tommee Tippee Ultimate Fit Orthodontic Dummies 18–36 Months, Silicone, Pack of 4
Available immediately
free shipping
  • Hautfreundlichkeit: air holes on both sides improve airflow and help reduce moisture build-up and skin irritation
  • Form und Passform: curved shield and symmetrical silicone teat provide a comfortable fit in any position; available for babies aged 0–6, 6–18 and 18–36 months
  • Design und Farben: colourful designs feature playful characters, contrasting details, patchwork checks and daisy prints
Our rating
9,8
very good
BIBS Colour Soother 4-Pack, Natural Rubber
BIBS Colour Soother 4-Pack, Natural Rubber
Available immediately
free shipping
  • free from BPA, PVC and phthalates for skin-friendly use
  • round shape and light weight for a comfortable fit similar to a mother's nipple
  • available in various colours with an aesthetic design
Our rating
9,8
very good
MAM Original Day & Night Dummies 18-36 Months, 4 Pack
MAM Original Day & Night Dummies 18-36 Months, 4 Pack
Available immediately
free shipping
  • Skin-friendly shield designed to feel soft against delicate skin and help reduce irritation around the mouth
  • Symmetrical teat and larger shield designed for babies and toddlers aged 18–36 months, helping the soother stay in place
  • Pack of four soothers with two daytime designs and two blue-themed glow-in-the-dark designs for easier visibility at night
Our rating
9,6
very good
900+ purchases last month
5. Bestseller
Tommee Tippee NightGlow Orthodontic Dummies 18–36 Months, 4 Pack
Tommee Tippee NightGlow Orthodontic Dummies 18–36 Months, 4 Pack
Available immediately
free shipping
  • Skin-friendly: ventilation holes on both sides improve airflow and help reduce moisture build-up and skin irritation
  • Shape and fit: a smooth, curved shield and symmetrical silicone teat provide a comfortable fit in any position
  • Design and colours: transparent shields feature moon and star designs in calming twilight tones, with a handle that glows in the dark after exposure to daylight
Our rating
9,6
very good
Tommee Tippee StayPut Silicone Dummies 0-6 Months, Pack of 4
Tommee Tippee StayPut Silicone Dummies 0-6 Months, Pack of 4
Available immediately
free shipping
  • Soft, skin-friendly food-grade silicone with a matte finish and reduced skin contact for improved airflow
  • Symmetrical teat and shield provide a comfortable fit in any orientation, while the balanced centre of gravity helps the soother stay in place for longer
  • Lightweight one-piece silicone design compatible with a soother clip for convenient access
Our rating
9,6
very good
400+ purchases last month
MAM Original 0-6M Dummies, Blue/Cream, 2 Pack
MAM Original 0-6M Dummies, Blue/Cream, 2 Pack
Available immediately
free shipping
  • Soft silicone teat with a skin-like feel and BPA- and BPS-free material
  • Symmetrical teat and easy-to-hold button designed for babies aged 2 to 6 months
  • Blue two-piece set with designs that may vary
Our rating
9,6
very good
Philips Avent Ultra Air Day & Night Soothers 0–6 Months, 4 Pack, SCF087/22
Philips Avent Ultra Air Day & Night Soothers 0–6 Months, 4 Pack, SCF087/22
Available immediately
free shipping
  • Extra-large air holes allow air to circulate around the skin, helping to keep it dry and comfortable
  • Symmetrical soothers for babies aged 0–6 months have soft, 100% food-grade silicone teats with a narrow neck for a comfortable fit
  • The set contains four soothers, including two daytime and two night-time soothers, with glow-in-the-dark caps for easier visibility at night
Our rating
9,6
very good
200+ purchases last month
Tommee Tippee StayPut Silicone Dummies 6-18 Months, 4 Pack
Tommee Tippee StayPut Silicone Dummies 6-18 Months, 4 Pack
Available immediately
free shipping
  • Skin friendliness: reduced skin contact, improved airflow and a soft matte finish for gentle comfort
  • Shape and fit: lightweight one-piece silicone soother with a symmetrical teat and shield that fits either way up and stays in place
  • Design and colours: compact one-piece design with no colour information provided
Our rating
9,6
very good
MAM Original Orthodontic Dummies 18–36 Months, Pink/Purple, 2 Pack
MAM Original Orthodontic Dummies 18–36 Months, Pink/Purple, 2 Pack
Available immediately
free shipping
  • Hautfreundlichkeit: weiches SkinSoft-Silikon mit hautähnlicher Oberfläche sowie ein abgerundeter Saugerschild mit grosszügigen Luftlöchern für empfindliche Haut
  • Form und Passform: flacher, symmetrischer Sauger und flacher, erhöhter Griffknopf für bequemes Tragen in jeder Position
  • Design und Farben: zweiteiliges Set in Pink mit Saugerschild und Griffknopf aus bio-basierten, nachwachsenden Materialien
Our rating
9,5
very good
BIBS Dummy Pacifier 2-Pack, Ivory/Sage, Size 1
BIBS Dummy Pacifier 2-Pack, Ivory/Sage, Size 1
Available immediately
free shipping
  • made from materials that are 100% free from bpa, pvc and phthalates, ensuring safety for your baby
  • round classic shield and cherry shaped nipple designed to mimic a mother’s breast, promoting a natural feel
  • available in a range of aesthetic and colourful designs to suit different preferences
Our rating
9,5
very good
300+ purchases last month
Dr. Brown’s Silicone Pacifier 0-6m, 3-Pack
Dr. Brown’s Silicone Pacifier 0-6m, 3-Pack
Available immediately
free shipping
  • lightweight and soft 100% silicone material ensures comfort for delicate skin
  • contoured butterfly-shaped shield fits comfortably from nose to cheeks
  • transparent design blends naturally, available in various colours
Our rating
9,5
very good
50+ purchases last month
MAM Silicone Soothers, 3-12 Months, 2 Pack, Grey
MAM Silicone Soothers, 3-12 Months, 2 Pack, Grey
Available immediately
free shipping
  • soft and gentle on baby's skin using high-quality silicone
  • lightweight and extra small design supports natural sucking and healthy oral development
  • available in several designs and colours
Our rating
9,5
very good
200+ purchases last month
Philips Avent Ultra Air Soothers 0–6 Months SCF087/01
Philips Avent Ultra Air Soothers 0–6 Months SCF087/01
Available immediately
free shipping
  • Extra-large air holes allow air to circulate around the skin, helping to keep it dry and comfortable
  • Symmetrical soft silicone teat designed for babies aged 0 to 6 months, with a shape that fits naturally in the mouth
  • BPA-free soothers with hard plastic parts made using 80% plant-based materials, excluding the silicone teat
Our rating
9,3
good
300+ purchases last month
NUK Signature Baby Dummy 6-18 Months, Heart-Shaped Silicone
NUK Signature Baby Dummy 6-18 Months, Heart-Shaped Silicone
Available immediately
free shipping
  • comfortable design for gentle touch on baby's skin
  • shape modelled on a mother's nipple for a natural feel and secure fit
  • features glow-in-the-dark designs with heart, star or bubble-shaped openings for easy locating at night
Our rating
9,1
good
400+ purchases last month
Philips Avent Soothie Soothers 0–6 Months SCF099/26
Philips Avent Soothie Soothers 0–6 Months SCF099/26
Available immediately
free shipping
  • Aus 100 % lebensmittelechtem Silikon gefertigt, frei von bedenklichen Chemikalien und Allergenen
  • Flexibler Sauger mit anatomischer Form für Neugeborene von 0 bis 6 Monaten; das einteilige Design folgt den Gesichtskonturen und lässt Platz für die Nase
  • Herzförmiger Schutzschild für hohen Tragekomfort; die Farbgebung ist nicht angegeben
Our rating
9,1
good
600+ purchases last month
Philips Avent Soothie Newborn Soothers 2 Pack SCF099/27
Philips Avent Soothie Newborn Soothers 2 Pack SCF099/27
Available immediately
free shipping
  • Made from soft, 100% food-grade silicone and free from hazardous chemicals and allergens
  • Heart-shaped shield follows the natural contours of the face without pressing against the nose, while the flexible teat is suitable for newborns aged 0–6 months
  • One-piece finger-held design supports natural suckling and allows easy cleaning without water becoming trapped in the teat
Our rating
9,0
good
300+ purchases last month
MAM Original Soothers 16+ Months Pack of 2
MAM Original Soothers 16+ Months Pack of 2
Available immediately
free shipping
  • made with extra soft silicone to be gentle on baby's skin helping to prevent irritation
  • symmetrical teat shape supports healthy oral development
  • rounded shield with air holes for comfortable wear and reduced skin irritation
Our rating
9,0
good
Philips Avent Ultra Air Pacifier 6-18m, SCF080/04
Philips Avent Ultra Air Pacifier 6-18m, SCF080/04
Available immediately
free shipping
  • allows baby's skin to breathe with extra large holes for air flow
  • lightweight shield for a comfortable fit
  • available in fashionable colours and designs
Our rating
9,0
good
MAM Air Soothers 16+ Months, 2 Pack, Blue/Cream
MAM Air Soothers 16+ Months, 2 Pack, Blue/Cream
Available immediately
free shipping
  • made from skin-soft silicone to ensure comfort for your baby
  • symmetrical design promotes correct jaw development
  • reduced skin contact shields with extra airflow minimise redness
Our rating
8,8
good
100+ purchases last month
NUK Signature Dummy 0-6M, BPA-Free Silicone, 2 Pack
NUK Signature Dummy 0-6M, BPA-Free Silicone, 2 Pack
Available immediately
free shipping
  • soft and flexible mouth shield designed for comfort during use
  • nipple shape adapted for a natural and satisfying feel, similar to breastfeeding
  • available in various charming designs, including stars and hearts
Our rating
8,4
good
700+ purchases last month
NUK Star Baby Dummy 0-6 Months, Blue Koala, 2 Count
NUK Star Baby Dummy 0-6 Months, Blue Koala, 2 Count
Available immediately
free shipping
  • extra-soft upper region that rests gently against the palate is gentle on delicate skin
  • round on top and flat underneath design allows for natural sucking movements, reducing pressure on teeth and jaws
  • glow-in-the-dark ring helps to locate the soother easily at night
Our rating
8,3
good
50+ purchases last month

Similar Pacifier comparisons

Pacifiers buying guide: How to choose the right product from the above Pacifiers test or comparison

Understanding Pacifiers: A Parent’s Guide to Soothing Choices

The Role of Pacifiers in Baby Soothing

Pacifiers are a common tool used by parents to soothe crying babies. They provide a sense of comfort and security, mimicking the natural sucking reflex. When babies suck on a pacifier, they may quiet down and feel more relaxed, which can be particularly helpful during stressful moments such as teething or when they are trying to fall asleep. It’s important to remember that while pacifiers can be a useful aid, they should be used in moderation to avoid dependency.

When to Introduce a Pacifier

Timing can be crucial when introducing a pacifier. Many experts recommend waiting until breastfeeding is established, typically about three to four weeks after birth. This allows the baby to become comfortable with nursing before introducing the pacifier. However, if your baby is fussy or has trouble settling, it might be beneficial to offer a pacifier sooner to provide them with that needed comfort.

Types of Pacifiers: Which One is Right for Your Baby?

Varieties of Pacifiers Available

There are several types of pacifiers designed to meet different needs and preferences. Traditional pacifiers are typically heart-shaped, with a nipple that mimics the breast. Orthodontic pacifiers feature a flattened or angled nipple that aims to support the natural development of a baby’s teeth and gums. Pacifiers with a variable flow design change the flow of milk according to the baby’s sucking rhythm, which can be especially useful as they grow. Each type has its pros and cons, so consider your child’s needs when making a choice.

Choosing the Right Shape and Size

Pacifiers also come in various shapes and sizes. The right size will depend on the age of your baby, as newborns require smaller pacifiers, while older infants may need larger ones. The shape of the pacifier can affect your baby’s acceptance, with some preferring round nipples and others favoring those that are flat. Trying out a few different shapes and sizes can help you find the pacifier that your baby prefers.

Materials and Safety: Key Factors for Peace of Mind

Understanding Pacifier Materials

Knowledge of pacifier materials is crucial for ensuring the safety of your baby. Most pacifiers are made from silicone or latex. Silicone is a popular choice because it is durable, easy to clean, and less likely to retain odors. Latex, while softer, can cause allergies in some babies. When choosing a pacifier, opting for BPA-free materials is recommended to avoid chemicals that could potentially harm your little one.

Safety Features to Consider

In addition to material, it’s essential to look for other safety features on pacifiers. A shield should be wide enough to prevent your baby from swallowing the pacifier. Look for designs with air holes in the shield to encourage airflow and prevent skin irritation. Regularly inspect pacifiers for wear and tear, and replace any that show signs of damage to keep your baby safe.

Choosing the Best Pacifier for Your Baby’s Age and Development

Age-Appropriate Pacifiers

As your baby grows, their pacifier needs may change. Newborns often require softer and smaller pacifiers, while older infants can handle more robust designs. Many manufacturers label pacifiers by age group, which can guide us in selecting the most suitable option. It’s beneficial to consider your baby’s developmental stage and preferences when choosing a pacifier.

Developmental Considerations

Beyond age, consider any developmental issues your baby may have. For example, if your baby is experiencing teething discomfort, a pacifier designed with teething textures can provide soothing relief. Observing how your baby interacts with a pacifier may also guide you in selecting the right one. If they seem to struggle with a particular shape or size, don’t hesitate to try another option.

Caring for Your Pacifier: Tips for Longevity and Cleanliness

Daily Cleaning Tips

Ensuring your pacifier remains clean is vital for your child’s health. Before the first use, sterilise it by boiling it in water for a few minutes, and make sure to check the manufacturer’s instructions for specific care guidelines. After each use, rinse it under warm running water and allow it to dry thoroughly. Avoid storing pacifiers in dirty places to maintain their cleanliness.

Storage for Longevity

Proper storage not only keeps pacifiers clean but also extends their lifespan. Use a dedicated container to store pacifiers when not in use, ensuring they are kept away from potential contaminants. Avoid exposing pacifiers directly to sunlight for prolonged periods, as this can degrade the material.

Table of contents
  1. Understanding Pacifiers: A Parent’s Guide to Soothing Choices
  2. Types of Pacifiers: Which One is Right for Your Baby?
  3. Materials and Safety: Key Factors for Peace of Mind
  4. Choosing the Best Pacifier for Your Baby’s Age and Development
  5. Caring for Your Pacifier: Tips for Longevity and Cleanliness

Overview

1. Comparison winner
Tommee Tippee Anytime 6 Pack Dummies
Our rating
9,8
very good
Tommee Tippee Anytime 6 Pack DummiesAvailable again soon
2. Best value
Tommee Tippee Ultimate Fit Orthodontic Dummies 18–36 Months, Silicone, Pack of 4
Our rating
9,8
very good
Tommee Tippee Ultimate Fit Orthodontic Dummies 18–36 Months, Silicone, Pack of 4Available immediately
BIBS Colour Soother 4-Pack, Natural Rubber
Our rating
9,8
very good
BIBS Colour Soother 4-Pack, Natural RubberAvailable immediately
MAM Original Day & Night Dummies 18-36 Months, 4 Pack
Our rating
9,6
very good
MAM Original Day & Night Dummies 18-36 Months, 4 PackAvailable immediately
5. Bestseller
Tommee Tippee NightGlow Orthodontic Dummies 18–36 Months, 4 Pack
Our rating
9,6
very good
Tommee Tippee NightGlow Orthodontic Dummies 18–36 Months, 4 PackAvailable immediately
Tommee Tippee StayPut Silicone Dummies 0-6 Months, Pack of 4
Our rating
9,6
very good
Tommee Tippee StayPut Silicone Dummies 0-6 Months, Pack of 4Available immediately
MAM Original 0-6M Dummies, Blue/Cream, 2 Pack
Our rating
9,6
very good
MAM Original 0-6M Dummies, Blue/Cream, 2 PackAvailable immediately
Philips Avent Ultra Air Day & Night Soothers 0–6 Months, 4 Pack, SCF087/22
Our rating
9,6
very good
Philips Avent Ultra Air Day & Night Soothers 0–6 Months, 4 Pack, SCF087/22Available immediately
Our product comparisons are:
Always up to date:
At most every 120 days, we update each category with new products and research developments in the top rankings. This ensures that our recommendations are always up to date
Neutral and independent:
Our tests and comparisons are objective and fact-based. Manufacturers have no influence on the ratings. We aim to provide greater transparency in the market, thereby promoting product quality.
Method-driven
In our tests & comparison tables, we only include products that meet our minimum standards. This ensures that you can find the perfect product for your needs from a wide selection.
Similar tests and comparisons - Infant Essentials