Updated:21 October 2026
Rank 1-15 of the best Eyeliner Pencils
Our recommendation Price Customer rating
1. Comparison winner
Julep Gel Eyeliner Pencil (Rich Brown)
Julep Gel Eyeliner Pencil (Rich Brown)
Available immediately
free shipping
  • intense colour with bold, vibrant pigments for striking eyes
  • smooth application with a gentle formula for easy use
  • long wear formula lasting over 10 hours without smudging or fading
Our rating
9,9
very good
100+ purchases last month
Avon Glimmerstick Eyeliner Blackest Black Pack of 3
Avon Glimmerstick Eyeliner Blackest Black Pack of 3
Available immediately
free shipping
  • intense colour in shade blackest black
  • easy to apply with creamy formula that glides smoothly
  • formulated for long-lasting wear up to 12 hours
Our rating
9,8
very good
3. Best value
Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer - Rich Brown
Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer - Rich Brown
Available immediately
free shipping
  • offers a deep, rich brown hue for striking eye definition
  • designed for effortless and smooth application
  • formulated for long-lasting wear throughout the day
Our rating
9,8
very good
4. Bestseller
NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil Black 0.34g
NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil Black 0.34g
Available immediately
free shipping
  • intense pigmentation for bold colour
  • easy to apply with twist-up pencil
  • long-lasting coverage with creamy formula
Our rating
9,8
very good
Revlon Color Stay Pencil Eyeliner N2 Brown
Revlon Color Stay Pencil Eyeliner N2 Brown
Available immediately
free shipping
  • intense colour for bold, striking eyes
  • smooth, easy application for precise lines
  • long wear formula lasts up to 16 hours
Our rating
9,6
very good
L'Oréal Superliner Le Smoky Eyeliner, 204 Brown Fusion
L'Oréal Superliner Le Smoky Eyeliner, 204 Brown Fusion
Check delivery time
free shipping
  • rich, intense colour for a dramatic look
  • easy application with integrated smudger
  • long-wearing formula for lasting colour
Our rating
9,6
very good
Maybelline Tattoo Liner Gel Pencil, Bold Brown
Maybelline Tattoo Liner Gel Pencil, Bold Brown
Available immediately
free shipping
  • delivers intense eye definition in one stroke
  • smooth application for even coverage
  • long-lasting tattoo effect resistant to water, sweat and disintegration
Our rating
9,6
very good
L'Oreal Voluminous Eyeliner, Black
L'Oreal Voluminous Eyeliner, Black
Available immediately
free shipping
  • intense black colour for striking definition
  • glides on easily for smooth application
  • formulated for long-lasting wear
Our rating
9,5
very good
Max Factor Masterpiece Kohl Kajal Eyeliner Pencil 001 Black
Max Factor Masterpiece Kohl Kajal Eyeliner Pencil 001 Black
Available immediately
free shipping
  • intense colour for dramatic eye looks
  • buttery-soft texture for easy application suitable for sensitive eyes
  • formulated for long-lasting wear, lasting up to 24 hours
Our rating
9,5
very good
Rimmel London Scandal'eyes Waterproof Eyeliner 001 Black
Rimmel London Scandal'eyes Waterproof Eyeliner 001 Black
Available immediately
free shipping
  • intense colour with high intensity for bold looks
  • ultra-smooth formula ensures easy application
  • long-lasting finish that is smudge-proof and sweat-proof
Our rating
9,5
very good
Max Factor Kohl Eyeliner Pencil, 20 Black, 4g
Max Factor Kohl Eyeliner Pencil, 20 Black, 4g
Available immediately
free shipping
  • intense black colour for a striking look
  • easy to apply with smooth glide for precise definition
  • long-lasting formula suitable for all-day wear
Our rating
9,1
good
Technic Twist Up Kohl Eyeliner Pencil
Technic Twist Up Kohl Eyeliner Pencil
Available immediately
free shipping
  • intense black colour for striking definition
  • suitable for easy and smooth application
  • formulated for long-lasting wear
Our rating
9,0
good
Rimmel London Soft Kohl Eyeliner Pencil, Jet Black
Rimmel London Soft Kohl Eyeliner Pencil, Jet Black
Available immediately
free shipping
  • Intense black colour for a bold look
  • Smooth and easy application with a soft, blendable formula
  • Long-lasting wear for up to 12 hours
Our rating
8,9
good
Max Factor Eye Liner, Brown 6
Max Factor Eye Liner, Brown 6
Available immediately
free shipping
  • bold and intense colour for standout eye looks
  • glides on smoothly for easy application
  • long-lasting wear ensures eyeliner stays put all day
Our rating
8,9
good
Revolution London Kohl Eyeliner Black
Revolution London Kohl Eyeliner Black
Available immediately
free shipping
  • intense colour with high pigmentation
  • smooth and creamy texture for easy application
  • long-wearing formula
Our rating
8,6
good
100+ purchases last month

Similar Eyeliner Pencil comparisons

Eyeliner Pencils buying guide: How to choose the right product from the above Eyeliner Pencils test or comparison

Introduction to Eyeliner Pencils: Finding the Right Fit for Your Eyes

Understanding Eyeliner Pencils

When it comes to enhancing our eyes, eyeliner pencils can be a game changer. They come in various formulas and types, making it important to find one that suits our specific eye shape, skin type, and personal style. The right eyeliner pencil can add definition, making our eyes appear larger and more striking, while poorly chosen products may smudge or irritate. With ample options on the market, let’s explore how to navigate this beauty staple effectively.

Choosing the Right Type for Your Eyes

We need to consider our natural eye shape when selecting an eyeliner pencil. For instance, if we have smaller eyes, a lighter or nude eyeliner on the waterline can create the illusion of larger peepers. If we have deep-set eyes, a soft, creamy pencil can be great for adding warmth without being too harsh. By understanding the illusion we want to create, we can better narrow down our choices.

Key Features to Look for in an Eyeliner Pencil: Texture, Pigmentation, and Longevity

Texture Matters

The texture of an eyeliner pencil can greatly influence our makeup application experience. Creamy formulas glide on smoothly and are often ideal for beginners or those looking for a soft, blended look. On the contrary, firmer pencils can provide a precise line, making them excellent for intricate designs. Finding a texture that aligns with how we apply makeup regularly will lead to a more satisfying use.

Pigmentation for Impact

Pigmentation is crucial when we want vibrant, eye-catching results. An eyeliner pencil should have rich colour payoff with just one stroke. We should consider testing colours in-store or ensuring brands have a reputation for quality if we shop online. The right pigmentation ensures that our eyeliner not only stands out but also lasts throughout the day without fading.

Prioritising Longevity

Long-lasting eyeliner is essential, particularly for busy days or nights out. We want to look for pencils that boast waterproof or smudge-proof claims, helping us to avoid touch-ups. Longevity not only covers wear time but also how well the colour adheres to our skin, especially in humid or hot conditions.

How to Apply Eyeliner Pencil for Different Looks: Daytime vs. Nighttime Styles

Daytime Application Techniques

During the day, we often favour a more understated look. We can apply a thin line close to the lash line for a subtle definition, perhaps using a brown pencil to soften the appearance. For those who prefer a bolder choice, a classic black pencil may work well, just remember to keep the line thin to avoid a heavy appearance.

Creating Nighttime Glam

For evening events, we can amp up our eyeliner game. Thicker lines or cat-eye styles can elevate our look instantly. We might also consider using a smudging technique for a smoky eye effect, which can easily be achieved by applying our eyeliner pencil and quickly blending it out with a brush or our finger before it sets. This transforms our look from daylight fresh to nighttime chic effortlessly.

Top Recommendations for Eyeliner Pencils: Our Picks for Every Budget

Budget-Friendly Options

We know that not everyone wants to break the bank for quality makeup. Several affordable eyeliner pencils in the market deliver impressive results without compromising on performance. Brands that offer creamy formulations in various shades can satisfy most preferences while being kind to our wallets.

Mid-Range Choices

For those willing to invest a little more, mid-range eyeliner pencils often strike the right balance between quality and cost. These typically feature better pigmentation and longer wear, making them ideal for daily use. We should consider brands that focus on skin-friendly ingredients, especially if we have sensitive skin.

Luxury Products Worth Trying

If budget allows, indulging in a luxury eyeliner pencil can be a treat. These products often come in sophisticated packaging and boast refined formulas with ingredients that care for the skin around the eyes. They might offer unique shades and finishes that are perfect for creating standout looks.

Caring for Your Eyeliner Pencil: Tips for Longevity and Best Use

Storing and Maintaining Your Eyeliner

To prolong the life of our eyeliner pencils, proper storage is key. Keeping them in a cool, dry place helps maintain their consistency and prevents breakage. Additionally, we should remember to sharpen them regularly to ensure a clean tip, which allows for better application precision.

Usage Tips for Optimal Results

When using our eyeliner pencil, understanding how to apply the right amount is essential. We can twist the pencil slightly instead of sharpening all the time, helping maintain the tip while preventing waste. If we ever notice our pencil becoming dry, adding a drop of oil can revive it, allowing for smoother application once again.

Table of contents
  1. Introduction to Eyeliner Pencils: Finding the Right Fit for Your Eyes
  2. Key Features to Look for in an Eyeliner Pencil: Texture, Pigmentation, and Longevity
  3. How to Apply Eyeliner Pencil for Different Looks: Daytime vs. Nighttime Styles
  4. Top Recommendations for Eyeliner Pencils: Our Picks for Every Budget
  5. Caring for Your Eyeliner Pencil: Tips for Longevity and Best Use

Overview

1. Comparison winner
Julep Gel Eyeliner Pencil (Rich Brown)
Our rating
9,9
very good
Julep Gel Eyeliner Pencil (Rich Brown)Available immediately
Avon Glimmerstick Eyeliner Blackest Black Pack of 3
Our rating
9,8
very good
Avon Glimmerstick Eyeliner Blackest Black Pack of 3Available immediately
3. Best value
Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer - Rich Brown
Our rating
9,8
very good
Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer - Rich BrownAvailable immediately
4. Bestseller
NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil Black 0.34g
Our rating
9,8
very good
NYX Mechanical Eye Pencil Black 0.34gAvailable immediately
Revlon Color Stay Pencil Eyeliner N2 Brown
Our rating
9,6
very good
Revlon Color Stay Pencil Eyeliner N2 BrownAvailable immediately
L'Oréal Superliner Le Smoky Eyeliner, 204 Brown Fusion
Our rating
9,6
very good
L'Oréal Superliner Le Smoky Eyeliner, 204 Brown FusionCheck delivery time
Maybelline Tattoo Liner Gel Pencil, Bold Brown
Our rating
9,6
very good
Maybelline Tattoo Liner Gel Pencil, Bold BrownAvailable immediately
L'Oreal Voluminous Eyeliner, Black
Our rating
9,5
very good
L'Oreal Voluminous Eyeliner, BlackAvailable immediately
Our product comparisons are:
Always up to date:
At most every 120 days, we update each category with new products and research developments in the top rankings. This ensures that our recommendations are always up to date
Neutral and independent:
Our tests and comparisons are objective and fact-based. Manufacturers have no influence on the ratings. We aim to provide greater transparency in the market, thereby promoting product quality.
Method-driven
In our tests & comparison tables, we only include products that meet our minimum standards. This ensures that you can find the perfect product for your needs from a wide selection.
Similar tests and comparisons - Eye Makeup